Misquote in ‘Two Guesses About Creativity’
Misquote: 6 issues found
Unmarked changes are underlined in wavy red. Hover over themTap them or see the explanation below. Checked using the pattern . and the Myers algorithm.
Suggested fix
[Unlike] any functionality that has ever been programmed to date, [creativity] can be achieved neither by a specification nor a test of the outputs. What is needed is nothing less than a breakthrough in philosophy, a new epistemological theory that explains how brains create explanatory knowledge and hence defines, in principle, without ever running them as programs, [...] [which] [algorithms] possess that functionality and which do not.
Original text
The upshot is that, unlike any functionality that has ever been programmed to date, this one can be achieved neither by a specification nor a test of the outputs. What is needed is nothing less than a breakthrough in philosophy, a new epistemological theory that explains how brains create explanatory knowledge and hence defines, in principle, without ever running them as programs, which algorithms possess that functionality and which do not.
Quote text
[Unlike] any functionality that has ever been programmed to date, [creativity] can be achieved neither by a specification nor a test of the outputs. What is needed is nothing less than a breakthrough in philosophy, a new epistemological theory that explains how brains create explanatory knowledge and hence defines, in principle, without ever running them as programs, which algorithms possess that functionality and which do not.
Diff
The‧[Unlike]‧upshot‧ is‧ that,‧ unlike any‧ functionality‧ that‧ has‧ ever‧ been‧ programmed‧ to‧ date,‧ this‧[creativity]‧one can‧ be‧ achieved‧ neither‧ by‧ a‧ specification‧ nor‧ a‧ test‧ of‧ the‧ outputs.‧ What‧ is‧ needed‧ is‧ nothing‧ less‧ than‧ a‧ breakthrough‧ in‧ philosophy,‧ a‧ new‧ epistemological‧ theory‧ that‧ explains *how* brains‧ create‧ explanatory‧ knowledge‧ and‧ hence‧ defines,‧ in‧ principle,‧ without‧ ever‧ running‧ them‧ as‧ programs, ‧*which* algorithms*‧possess‧ that‧ functionality‧ and‧ which‧ do‧ not.
added in the quote
removed from the original
wavy not marked as a change
‧ space
Part-by-part explanation
| # | Part | Valid? | Explanation |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |
|
✓ yes | Deletion is followed by a valid insertion. |
| 2 |
[Unlike] |
✓ yes | Insertion is properly bracketed. |
| 3 |
‧ |
||
| 4 |
|
✓ yes | Deletion is followed by a valid insertion. |
| 5 |
[creativity] |
✓ yes | Insertion is properly bracketed. |
| 6 |
‧ |
||
| 7 |
|
× no | Deletions must be indicated, eg by ‘[...]’ or [replacement]. |
| 8 |
* |
× no | Insertions must be surrounded by [brackets]. |
| 9 |
which |
||
| 10 |
|
× no | Deletions must be indicated, eg by ‘[...]’ or [replacement]. |
| 11 |
* |
||
| 12 |
|
× no | Insertions must be surrounded by [brackets]. |
| 13 |
algorithms |
||
| 14 |
|
× no | Deletions must be indicated, eg by ‘[...]’ or [replacement]. |
| 15 |
‧
|
× no | A single added space must either follow or precede a valid insertion. |
| 16 |
possess‧ |
Notes
Wrong emphasis
Embed this check
<script type="text/javascript" src="https://quote-checker.com/diffs/misquote-in-two-guesses-about-creativity/embed.js"></script>