Home
‘Quote check of David Deutsch’s ‘The Beginning o...’
Fork
Forking
‘Quote check of David Deutsch’s ‘The Beginning of Infinity’’
by Dennis Hackethal
Original
Text
For instance, the philosopher John Searle has placed the AI project in the following historical perspective: for centuries, some people have tried to explain the mind in mechanical terms, using similes and metaphors based on the most complex machines of the day. First the brain was supposed to be like an immensely complicated set of gears and levers. Then it was hydraulic pipes, then steam engines, then telephone exchanges – and, now that computers are our most impressive technology, brains are said to be computers. But this is still no more than a metaphor, says Searle, and there is no more reason to expect the brain to be a computer than a steam engine. But there is. A steam engine is not a universal simulator. But a computer is, so expecting it to be able to do whatever neurons can is not a metaphor: it is a known and proven property of the laws of physics as best we know them.
Accurately reproduce the original text. Don’t change it – copy/pasting works best. Retain inline formatting by using
markdown syntax
.
Source
Where is the original text from? Provide a link or, when quoting from a book, provide at least the author and title. The more information the better.
Preview of original
Quote
Text
[John Searle argues] there is no more reason to expect the brain to be a computer than a steam engine. But there is. A steam engine is not a universal simulator. But a computer is, so expecting it to be able to do whatever neurons can is not a metaphor: it is a known and proven property of the laws of physics as best we know them.
Quote the original. Do not use any surrounding quotation marks. If you are reusing a pre-existing quote, don’t change it; follow the guidelines given for the original text.
Source (optional)
If you are reusing a pre-existing quote, provide a source. Again, the more information the better.
Preview of quote
Ellipsis
Used for omissions. The default is ‘[...]’, but ‘. . .’ and variations thereof are also commonly used. If you are reusing a pre-existing quote, reflect its use of ellipsis.
Advanced
You can adjust additional settings below. Odds are you don’t need to.
Pattern
/
/m
A Ruby regular expression determining what is considered a diffable chunk. Defaults to
.
for individual characters. Use
\w+
to compare whole words instead.
Diffing algorithm
Myers (default)
Minimal
Patience
Histogram
Pick the algorithm that generates the most semantic diff for your purposes. Myers often works best. Different algorithms sometimes produce the same results.
Create permalink
Title
Give a descriptive title.
Your real name (optional)
Provide your name if you want.
Notes (optional)
Anything you want to add such as credits, context, instructions for how to read the diff, etc.
Preview of notes
Save publicly
Please note